by Ian Duggan

No garden ornament will have appeared on our television and movie screens more than garden gnomes. For the kids in recent years, we have had ‘Gnomeo and Juliet’, a reimagining of the Shakespeare tragedy, and its sequel ‘Sherlock Gnomes’, which centred around the investigation of disappearing gnomes. Most recently, ‘Wallace & Gromit: Vengeance Most Fowl’ explored Wallace’s invention of a robotic garden gnome named Norbot. For an adult audience, going back to 2001, many will remember ‘Amélie’, the romantic comedy where a garden gnome belonging to the title character’s reclusive father is kept in his garden as a memento of his late wife, who disliked it. Amélie secretly steals the gnome and takes it on a traveling adventure, sending photos of it in front of famous landmarks to convince her father to leave his home and live life more fully. And screening right now, we have a new Australian TV show, simply titled ‘Gnomes’, where an evil entity brings to life a city’s garden gnomes, who go on a killer rampage.

This Australian show certainly isn’t the first TV show to centre on garden gnomes. Going back to 1972, we could watch a British comedy TV show called ‘The Gnomes of Dulwich’. In New Zealand, this was at a time when we only had one TV channel. It wasn’t until 1974 that we got a second, or colour for that matter. So, if it was on TV, you either had to watch it, in black-and-white, or find something else to do.

First aired in the UK is 1969, in colour, ‘The Gnomes of Dulwich’ took a few years before it was shown in New Zealand. One thing that likely made this series sound promising was that it was written by Jim Perry, already familiar in New Zealand as the co-creator of ‘Dad’s Army’ (1968–1977), which had begun screening in New Zealand in March 1970. Perry went on to co-write other TV favourites, including ‘It Ain’t Half Hot Mum’ (1974–1981) and ‘Hi-de-Hi!’ (1980–1988), with David Croft.

In 1971, Christchurch’s The Press reported that:

“The Gnomes of Dulwich” is an unusual comedy series which stars Terry Scott and Hugh Lloyd… in new—and inhuman—roles. It was bought from the B.B.C. by the N.Z.B.C. recently, but it is unlikely to be scheduled for some time.[i]

The exact reasons for the delay, however, are unclear. The premise certainly sounded interesting, although in today’s terms, potentially problematic:

Scott and Lloyd appear as a couple of foot-high garden gnomes who spend their “lives” sitting by a rock pool in a London suburban garden.

Big and Smail are a pair of stone-built, traditionally solid, slightly old-fashioned garden gnomes for whom life, surprisingly, has its problems. In the first place they have only the vaguest idea of what the “Human Beans” who run the world are all about—they think cars are part of some esoteric religion.

In the second—and this comes much nearer to them —they are being surrounded in gardens all round them by dozens of cheap and very inferior plastic gnomes, imported from Hong Kong. These unwanted immigrants include something Big and Small have never encountered before—girl gnomes. Needless to say, their attitude towards them is considerably more tolerant than towards their male compatriots.[ii]

Despite how it sounds today, the website “Curious British Telly” noted in 2016 that rather than it “being an example of the worst excesses of creative whimsy in the 1960s, this Jimmy Perry sitcom set out to be a satire on immigration and the accompanying racial fears blighting the UK at the time…”. As such, the themes still sound as relevant today as ever. [iii]

Nevertheless, the same website reassessed the series in 2018, following a reread of the scripts of the first two episodes, which are preserved in the BBC written archives. They noted that, despite its intentions:

“it soon loses any satirical clout due to the cavalcade of sexist and racist jibes ingrained into the script. The female gnomes, for example, offer very little aside from giving the male gnomes something to salivate over… And, yes, there are plenty of instances of caricatured Chinese language being played for laughs by the plastic gnomes… While I sincerely doubt that Perry is racist, it appears to be more a legacy of the times. A legacy which would also render It Ain’t Half Hot unrepeatable for the last few decades”.

If you want to go further down the rabbit hole, I highly recommend that websites synopsis: Curious British Telly: The Gnomes of Dulwich

Surviving shot from ‘The Gnomes of Dulwich’.

Overall, The Gnomes of Dulwich was not considered a success in Britain. “The overall impression of the series was that it was childish, contained too many smutty jokes and, most frankly, one viewer described it as “absolute rubbish“.[iv] The BBC produced on six half-hour episodes.

Back to New Zealand, how was the show greeted? The show began screening on Monday nights in July 1972, following sports programme Grandstand.

Press, 17 July 1972, P4

Following the first episode, ‘Pandora’ – in a regular column that reviewed TV shows – began:

The two new programmes which gave Monday night’s viewing particular promise were both disappointing”.[v]

From there, they didn’t hold back:

The idea of giving a set of stone garden gnomes speech and thought, to comment on the passing scene, current problems and personalities, is by no means a bad one as the basis for a comedy series, but “The Gnomes of Dulwich”, featuring Terry Scott and Hugh Lloyd was fearfully feeble. These two in “Hugh and I” were a second-rate team; this series, from a first impression only, to be sure, is going to be worse. The lines were lamentably weak, although the innuendo was laid on as thickly as the make-up. It took three hours to put the paint on the gnomes before each day of shooting, it has been reported. It seems to have been a graven waste of time.[vi]

Soon came regular viewers’ opinions. Ellen M Barwell wrote to the paper to say:

First “Up Pompeii,” now “The Gnomes of Dulwich”. One can not help feeling that there is a little pathos in the situation of elderly “comedians” who, along with donning their corsets, imagine that by a certain amount of eye-rolling and frequent use of the word “sex” that they are screamingly funny. Ho hum. Pardon me while I yawn.[vii]

The next day, ‘Half Each Way’ wrote:

The Bill Cosby show never failed to irritate me, and I do not mourn his passing. But I now find “The Gnomes of Dulwich” is even worse — pitiful in fact, and not funny in the least. Perhaps I lack a funny-bone.[viii]

Things didn’t get better. Pandora, following episode two, was even less impressed:

“And as for “The Gnomes of Dulwich” . . . the first week was deplorable. This was worse, and John Laurie might well feel embarrassed about appearing in it. On this showing “The Gnomes of Dulwich” is pitifully puerile”.[ix]

A couple of weeks later, Pandora was back. Was the series improving?

“…but then there were those perishing gnomes again. To be fair, they were a shade better than before, but still deplorable. There was the useful idea of having the stone gnomes wage war on the plastics next door, which allowed Terry Scott to indulge in some ponderous paraphrasing of speeches by Chamberlain and Churchill, and to fling in a bit of Kitchener and the arms race. But in “The Gnomes of Dulwich,” if the writers stumble on a pun or witticism, it is belaboured unmercifully. The redeeming feature of the series is that it is only six programmes in length.  And we must be nearing the end now”.[x]

Pandora returned to stick the boot in again at the series’ conclusion:

“Those garden pests, “The Gnomes of Dulwich,” have gone, for which many viewers will be thankful. The last of the series on Monday, was the best of a very poor lot. The Downing Street part of the sketch had its moments”.[xi]

…which was backed up by Viewer “UGH! And Again Ugh!”:

“I heartily endorse “Pandora’s” comments on this flop. Not slightly sick, but very, very sick. It would be interesting to know the name of the person or persons responsible for the selection of this tripe”.[xii]

So, as in the UK, The Gnomes of Dulwich was not overly appreciated in New Zealand. But what if you want to assess the quality for yourself? Well, you are out of luck. Following a repeat screening in the UK in 1970, in a 10 pm Monday timeslot, all of the episodes were wiped from the BBC archives.[xiii] As the BBC notes, recordings of programmes made through the 1960s and ‘70s were made for short term broadcasting reasons, not for the long term. The BBC had no official archiving policy until 1978.[xiv] Many series are included in these losses, including episodes of Hancock’s Half Hour, Dad’s Army, Z-Cars and, perhaps most notably, many of the early episodes of Dr Who. For the latter, a number have since been recovered from copies sent to overseas broadcasters, including New Zealand. Could we hold the key to the missing “The Gnomes of Dulwich” episodes? I’m not sure it is something we should wish for…


References

[i] Scott and Lloyd. Press, 1 May 1971, P4

[ii] ibid

[iii] Curious British Telly: 25 Curious British TV Comedies That Only Had One Series

[iv] Curious British Telly: The Gnomes of Dulwich

[v] New programmes were of limited appeal. Press, 19 July 1972, P4

[vi] ibid

[vii] Viewers’ Views. 20 July 1972, P4

[viii] Viewers Views, 21 July 1972, P4

[ix] Welland play was best of poor lot. Press, 26 July 1972, P4

[x] America again under the TV microscope. Press, 9 August 1972, P4

[xi] Press, 23 August 1972, P4

[xii] Viewers’ views. Press, 18 December 1972, P4

[xiii] Curious British Telly: The Gnomes of Dulwich

[xiv] BBC Archives – Wiped, Missing and Lost

Leave a Reply